News
Shared equity concerns raised
A SCHEME designed to help first-time buyers has come in for criticism after it was revealed that Carmarthenshire County Council had lost crucial documentation relating to at least one of the properties concerned.
It has also been claimed that the advice given to buyers looking to sell shared equity properties has been at best contradictory.
Because the issues raised in this story could affect others who have not contacted The Herald, we have taken the decision not to identify either the person affected or the area in which this took place.
Our main source for this story was happy to be named, but as his issues with Carmarthenshire County Council have been largely resolved, we decided that identifying him, and the location, could cause problems for others who may face an impact from this. For the purpose of this article we have called him ‘Jon’.
WHAT HAPPENED
Jon’s partner had entered into an affordable housing deal with Carmarthenshire County Council (CCC) for a property in the Machynys area of Llanelli in 2010. She took out a mortgage for 70% of the property’s value, with CCC holding the other 30%.
However, as a result of changes in their circumstances, the two bedroom property was no longer sufficient for their needs, and the couple, who have two children, decided to sell.
‘MIXED MESSAGES’
Jon told The Herald that the couple were told that they could sell the property on the open market, and in June 2014 put the house up for sale with an estate agent. After several people viewed the property, a prospective purchaser from England offered to pay £112,000 cash for the property.
The couple informed the council that they had a buyer, and went to a solicitor to sort out the necessary documentation, at an estimated cost of £1,300.
However, at this point, Jon said that the council’s legal department ‘put a block’ on the sale, saying that it didn’t meet the terms of the unilateral agreement drawn up by the council.
“We were £1,300 out of pocket, and we still couldn’t move,” Jon told us. At this point the sale fell through.
Questions were also raised about the property’s valuation. Carmarthenshire County Council put the value at £135,000 following the advice of its property valuation team. However, three independent valuations which Jon instigated claimed the property was worth £112-114,000 – something he says was borne out by comparable house prices in the area at the time.
More worryingly, he said, the council apparently had ‘no procedure in place’ for the sale of shared equity housing: “We were told that the council had not allowed for people’s circumstances changing,” he added.
Following a subsequent meeting, and after local MP Nia Griffith got involved with the case, Carmarthenshire County Council hired a registered independent investigator.
PAPERWORK ‘LOST’
In August 2015, the advice given was that the couple had the paperwork in place to back his claim of 70% ownership. The council was unable to provide any evidence to the contrary.
This implies that Carmarthenshire County Council had failed to keep a record of a property transaction. It has been alleged that other homeowners in a shared equity mortgage agreement may be affected by this.
In terms of selling the property on, Jon was told that he would be given a list of people who qualified for the shared equity scheme, and that he and his partner would ‘have to get in touch’ with these to identify an interested party.
However, when Jon phoned the department on Monday, he was told that shared equity properties were only dealt with on one day a week.
In a subsequent meeting with a council legal advisor, Jon was asked the value of houses in the area of the same size.
“We didn’t want to make money out of this – we just needed a bigger house,” he told us.
STRESS
By this stage, the stress was beginning to tell on the couple, one of whom had been forced to sleep on the sofa every weekend for more than a year already. Jon told us that plans for their wedding had been affected by the uncertainty still surrounding the sale.
“They [Carmarthenshire County Council] didn’t care about the stress they were putting us through, or our children’s welfare,” he claimed.
At this stage, Carmarthenshire County Council was still claiming that owned 49% of the property rather than 30%. However, after ‘several ding-dongs’ it emerged that CCC was unable to locate ANY documents relating to the ownership of the house. “They didn’t have a leg to stand on,” Jon recalled.
At a meeting in October 2015 – more than a year after their initial sale had been blocked – the council accepted the couple’s valuation and 70% ownership claim, and asked how they wished to proceed.
“I told them; all we want is to be able to sell our home,” Jon said. “I said there needed to be a procedure in place to stop this happening to other people.”
Carmarthenshire County Council agreed to buy the couple’s share of the property back for cash. In addition, they agreed to cover legal fees up to this point, and ‘graciously’ offered £500 cash settlement for their trouble.
THE ‘AFFORDABLE HOUSING’ SCHEME
Carmarthenshire County Council describes the Affordable Homes Scheme as follows: “Affordable homes are aimed at people who can get a mortgage and earn an average income, but cannot afford to buy a suitable home at open market prices.
“They’re usually sold on a shared equity basis – this means that you would buy a percentage share of the home, and we – or a Housing Association – will own the remaining share of the home (up to the market value).
“To be eligible, you must live or work full time, in Carmarthenshire, or have a long standing local connection to Carmarthenshire, such as immediate family within the area. Your income before tax should be a minimum of £15,000 a year. This figure can include benefits other than Housing Benefit. Priority is given to council and housing association tenants.”
In a list of Frequently Asked Questions on the council’s website, it is explicitly stated that to purchase an affordable home ‘you must be registered on our affordable homes register.’ This would preclude any open market sale.
“If you are interested in a particular development”, The website adds, “we will ask for further financial details from you including a mortgage certificate. We will then prioritise households according to our affordable housing allocations policy. We will write to let you know if you have been successful and the next steps you will need to take.”
It is difficult to reconcile these arrangements with those suggested to Jon. It is implied that any buying or selling of affordable homes will be carried out through the council, rather than personally by the co- owner. At the least this raises questions over whether the resale of shared equity homes had been properly thought through.
As Nia Griffith pointed out: “You would never expect a tenant vacating a place to find the next tenant.”
Given that the couple were initially advised to advertise the property on the open market, this indicates a lack of communication between different departments.
The Herald has been told that an email to Jon from the council’s Chief Executive acknowledged failings, and suggested that a review of the council’s own processes was under way. Whether or not this is the case remains to be seen. SHARED EQUITY ISSUES
The Herald has seen the original mortgage documents relating to the sale of the property. These clearly indicate that the mortgage taken out was for a 70%/30% split between the purchaser and Carmarthenshire County Council. This equated to £67,480 of a total agreed property price of £96,400. The mortgage papers make clear reference to a 30% discount.
However, after Jon and his partner announced their intention to sell, a letter from the council informed them that they had purchased 51.9% of the property, for £67,480, and that the original open market price was £130,000.
It is then suggested that their share of the property could be sold for around £70,000, which equates to 51.9% of the market valuation of £135,000.
These figures have been heavily disputed by Jon, who paid for three separate valuations. These put the value of the house between £110,000 and £120,000. At £120,000, a 70% stake would equate to £84,000. 70% of the council’s valuation would equate to £94,500.
This would have meant that by either valuation, Jon and his partner would have lost between £10- 25,000. While the amount initially paid was agreed by both parties, the council’s claim appears to be based on what could charitably be described as an over-estimate.
Given that the council failed to provide paperwork to back up their case, it could be suggested that the valuation is an extrapolation based on the flawed premise of a 52-48% split, with an increase in value along the lines of inflation.
NIA GRIFFITH MP
The Herald spoke to Nia Griffith, who Jon said was instrumental in assisting him in his struggle with the council.
Ms Griffith said that the main issue was the way in which the scheme had been handled by Carmarthenshire County Council, and the lack of certain provisions.
“I really think that the issue here is about how Carmarthenshire County Council manages this type of scheme,” she told us.
“If you say ‘we are giving firsttime buyers a leg-up’ by offering a 70-30 split equity mortgage, you have to work out what to do when they need to move on.
“I think the situation of any young purchaser, their needs, will change – most first time buyers will need a larger property at some stage.
“So, regardless of that everyone would expect families’ circumstances could change, that wasn’t taken into account.
“The council didn’t seem to have a clear idea about what to do.”
Ms Griffith described the treatment of Jon and his family as ‘utterly appalling.’
“At one stage they had a cash purchaser ready to go ahead, and when they asked CCC for permission they were told they couldn’t sell it on the open market,” she pointed out. As has been mentioned, this led to delays of over a year in selling their property. “The council has been guilty of sending out ‘mixed messages.”
“Carmarthenshire County Council has set up a system where you could purchase but had no strategy for exiting,” she added.
“There has been a strategic failure in the sense that they have not thought out how the scheme should work, and a practical failure where they have lost the relevant paperwork.
“The reason Jon managed to prove that they owned 70% of the equity was because the mortgage company noted the detail.
“The disgraceful thing CCC had done was no paperwork to this effect, so the onus was on the first time buyer to prove this.
“To be fair the council accepted what it had to do when the investigation raised these issues – whatever happened had clearly been badly mismanaged, which was probably why the Head of Housing was prepared to bring in outside consultants.
“These are things that CCC has to get right: How to maintain a bank of affordable properties; how to enable the value of a property to grow, while at the same time keeping it as an affordable property; When devising the scheme, they have to make sure that staff are trained to avoid mixed messages.
“They need to find a way to make sure that no one should go through that agony when going to sell a property.
“Another question which remains unanswered is that if the property is sold on the open market what would happen to the affordable housing provision?
“Whilst it is laudable in its aims the details need to be watertight.
“You would never expect a tenant vacating a place to find the next tenant.”
The Herald asked Carmarthenshire County Council whether or not any review of shared equity mortgage policy had been initiated following the terms of their eventual agreement with Jon.
We also asked whether there were any outstanding issues pertaining to documentation with other shared equity properties, given reports that other residents had been given similarly misleading valuations.
Robin Staines from Head of Housing and Public Protection, told us: “As has been confirmed, the matter relating to this property is resolved. Unfortunately, documentation relating to a small number of shared equity agreements were destroyed in error during an office relocation. We have since contacted all affected owneroccupiers to apologise and review their individual agreements. The council has reviewed its shared equity mortgage policy due to recent changes in lender practices.”
Community
Llanelli Festival of Remembrance brings week to an emotional close
Review: Music, tribute and reflection at Ffwrnes Theatre, with Carmarthen Symphonic Wind Band, Meibion Elli and young local performers
Review by Robert Lloyd
It would be hard to think of a better way to end a week of Remembrance than this special festival staged at Llanelli’s Ffwrnes Theatre.
It was an evening which provided just the right measures of tribute, respect, dignity and emotion.
And it was fitting that it ended with a special presentation to Royal British Legion Llanelli branch president Ray Batsford, a veteran who has provided years of sterling service to the community.
The Llanelli branch of the RBL is in fine shape, on the evidence of a Poppy Appeal estimated to have raised £24,000 locally this year.
The branch’s organisation of the Festival of Remembrance was magnificent from start to finish, helped by the Rev Eldon Phillips as compère and Cerith Owens as artistic director.
The highlight of the evening was an impressive Drumhead Service of Remembrance, conducted by RBL Llanelli branch chaplain the Rev Delyth Richards. The silence was impeccably observed and there were many tears shed among the audience.
The festival was blessed with musical support from the Carmarthen Symphonic Wind Band, performing under the baton of their new musical director, Rhodri Rutherford.
On a day when Welsh pride and passion were well to the fore, it was appropriate that Meibion Elli should bring their own brand of powerful and emotional male voice singing to the stage.
The evening began with the muster of banners, with the symphonic band providing the musical background of Great Little Army and Arromanches.
Meibion Elli’s first set, under musical director D Eifion Thomas, included the powerhouse Gwahoddiad, the Welsh version of Anthem from Chess and the Elvis Presley classic Precious Lord. The featured soloist was award-winning baritone John ‘Pontyberem’ Thomas.
The first soloist of the evening was Scott Holmes, a member of the Llanelli-based Loud Applause Rising Stars team. He was totally tuned in to the emotion of the evening with performances of Bui Doi (Dust of Life) from Miss Saigon and the classic Empty Chairs at Empty Tables from Les Misérables.
The youngsters of Ysgol Bryngwyn Comprehensive School, drawn from Years 7 to 11, were a delight, with a set which included When I Grow Up from Matilda and John Lennon’s classic Imagine.
The Carmarthen Symphonic Wind Band took centre stage with The Great Escape, Tell My Father, featuring Rhodri Rutherford, Dafydd y Garreg Wen and Jitterbug.
Soloist Betsan Daniel, also a member of Loud Applause Rising Stars, was a late replacement for the unwell Lauren Elizabeth Williams, but she displayed wonderful composure with A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square and Adre, the celebrated Caryl Parry Jones tear-jerker.
The wind band stirred the soul with Elgar’s Nimrod, before Meibion Elli concluded with You’ll Never Walk Alone, Ashokan Farewell and The Mansions of the Lord.
David Blewitt, pipe major of the City of Swansea Pipe Band, provided bagpipe accompaniment to the Service of Remembrance, which included the hymns Efengyl Tangnefedd and O God, Our Help in Ages Past.
There were prayers before the Exhortation, the Last Post, the Silence and the Kohima Epitaph. The festival also featured an emotional poetry reading by Welsh Guards veteran Chris Beynon and a short speech by Geraint Davies reflecting on the Iraq War.

Find out more about the Royal British Legion’s work locally on the Friends of The Royal British Legion – Llanelli Branch Facebook page.
Main image: The Rev Delyth Richards conducts the Drumhead Service of Remembrance at Ffwrnes Theatre, Llanelli (Image supplied).
Community
Drug-driver jailed after repeated failures to comply with community order
Jay Francis Cockburn was sentenced to 12 weeks after admitting a breach involving missed probation and treatment appointments
A DRUG-DRIVER has been jailed for 12 weeks after repeatedly failing to comply with a community order imposed for offences in Ceredigion.
Jay Francis Cockburn, 35, of no fixed abode, admitted the breach at a hearing on Monday (November 9).
He was at Haverfordwest courthouse but appeared before a Llanelli magistrates’ bench, according to the court register.
The proceedings concerned a community order made at Aberystwyth Magistrates’ Court on July 1. Cockburn had been convicted in October 2025 of two drug-driving offences arising from the same incident at Llanafan on July 3 that year.
He had driven a Ford Mondeo with controlled substances in his blood above the specified limits.
The breach proceedings listed failures to comply with a planned home visit on August 4, a drug rehabilitation appointment on October 2 and supervision appointments on October 6, October 20 and November 3.
Magistrates revoked the community order and re-sentenced Cockburn for the original offences, imposing two 12-week prison terms to run at the same time.
In their recorded reasons, the bench described his failure to comply as wilful and persistent and said the driving could have had devastating consequences.
The court concluded that his failure to comply with previous community orders for the offence demonstrated an unwillingness to engage with probation, and that the prison sentence could not be suspended.
No order was made for costs.
Education
Carmarthenshire councillors call for permanent nursing at special schools
Carmarthenshire Council’s HQ at County Hall (Pic: Richard Youle)
Councillors seek an urgent plan with Hywel Dda to provide nursing support for pupils with complex medical needs
PERMANENT nursing should be available at all specialist additional learning needs (ALN) facilities in Carmarthenshire, according to councillors.
They backed a motion brought by Labour councillors Martyn Palfreman and Edward Skinner which said pupils in such venues often needed complex medical interventions during the school day.
“These include tube feeding, catheterisation, tracheotomy care, monitoring and responding to seizures, and the timely administration of prescribed rescue medication,” it said.
“Despite the dedication of educational staff in such establishments, who provide outstanding care for pupils and have undertaken training to meet individual healthcare needs, it should be recognised that they are not medically qualified.
“As such, they should not be expected to be responsible for recognising clinical deterioration, assessing complex medical symptoms or responding to potentially life-threatening medical emergencies that arise during school time.”
There was particular focus on Ysgol Heol Goffa, Llanelli, where many pupils have very complex needs and where, according to the motion, the head teacher has sought permanent onsite nursing provision for more than five years.
“Parents have expressed serious and continuing anxiety about the safety of their children in the absence of a registered nurse permanently based on site,” it said.
Discussions have taken place between the council and Hywel Dda University Health Board and the motion called for an urgent meeting between them and other parties in a bid to agree a “funded and time-bound plan”.
The motion also said a jointly-commissioned clinical risk assessment for every pupil with complex or life-limiting medical needs should be done immediately.
Speaking at a meeting of full council Cllr Palfreman said providing the right support could in some cases “can be a matter of life or death”. He and others praised the work of teachers and teaching assistants.
Cllr Crish Davies said: “Every parent deserves peace of mind that comes from knowing that their child is in safe hands.” Some of them, she said, lived with worries “we can barely imagine”.
Cllr Deryk Cundy said five children at a special school had palliative care, seven had feeding valves, three had shunts, and 22 had epilepsy. He added that many children could not articulate their concerns.
Cllr Gareth John said he supported the motion with two reservations – that it was logical for the outcome of discussions between the council and the health board to reach an outcome before cabinet discussed the motion, should it be approved, and an acknowledgement the council could lobby but couldn’t create a health workforce “that may not even exist”.
Cllr Jane Tremlett, cabinet member for integrated health and children and adult services, said: “Every child with complex needs should be able to attend school safely, with dignity and with confidence that the appropriate support is available if they need it.”
She said school staff shouldn’t be expected to be healthcare professionals. “We need absolutely clarity about where professional responsibility sits and how that provision is commissioned and funded,” she said.
She said different schools might need different models of provision, and added: “What matters is it’s safe, clinically approved and sustainable.”
Cllr Glynog Davies, cabinet member for education, called on the health board “to take up their responsibility seriously” and said the Welsh Government should provide clarity on what they expected councils to provide.
Responding to the motion, Sharon Daniel, director of nursing, quality and patient experience at Hywel Dda University Health Board, said: “The health and wellbeing of all children and young people is fundamental to their ability to learn, thrive and reach their potential, and is a priority for us.
“We support the children and young people at Ysgol Heol Goffa with a specialist/community children nursing service to meet their universal health needs, and through the provision of training for staff at the school.
“We provide specialist support, ensuring each child and young person with healthcare needs can be cared for competently and confidently within the school environment. Through continued partnership working and a shared commitment to improvement, we will support ongoing actions to strengthen provision and ensure the best possible outcomes for the pupils and staff at Ysgol Heol Goffa.”
-
Community1 day agoLlanelli Festival of Remembrance brings week to an emotional close
-
News1 week agoGateway Resort owner loses appeals over glamping pods and clubhouse extensions
-
Education3 weeks agoBT Work Ready programme helps Llanelli pupils build skills for future careers
-
Education1 week agoLlanelli special school pupils welcome plans for larger school with outdoor space
-
Education4 days agoCarmarthenshire councillors call for permanent nursing at special schools
-
Business1 week agoFast Forward sets its sights on the next stage of growth
-
News8 months agoBoxer plans move to Llanelli church to expand community club
-
News12 months agoLlanelli Town AFC women’s team secures new sponsor

